RheumaView · Olga Goodman, MD
Bertolotti syndrome: why the lower back may still hurt
A different shape at the base of the spine can sometimes contribute to pain. Learn what the image shows, what it cannot prove, and what to discuss with your doctor.
On this page
01Start here: the essentials
- A transitional vertebra is a developmental variation where the lower spine meets the sacrum. Many people with it have no symptoms.
- The term Bertolotti syndrome is used when pain is attributed to this anatomy after clinical assessment.
- Persistent pain does not automatically mean that inflammatory arthritis has returned or that a biologic has failed. Different pain mechanisms can coexist.
02The video
English-language film · 3 min 55 sec · Complete transcript below in the language of this page.
Read the complete video transcript ↓
In these cases, remission of spondyloarthritis was confirmed through clinical assessment and supporting investigations. Even in confirmed remission, pain can persist for another reason, such as an accessory articulation. The film explains this coexistence. Unchanged X-rays show structural stability over the interval; on their own, they cannot confirm remission or exclude active inflammation.
03Understand the image

Tap the image to enlarge it. The written explanation below also describes the labels.
At the bottom of the spine, a vertebra has a bony projection on each side. In this example, the projection on the patient’s left is enlarged and meets the sacrum through an additional articulation, sometimes called a “false joint.” The sacrum is the broad bone at the base of the spine.
This is a developmental feature. It may alter the load on nearby joints and discs. The additional contact can develop degenerative changes, but the shape alone cannot tell us whether it hurts.
04How it is assessed
A clinician asks where the pain is, when it began and how it changes with movement, rest or position. Examination helps assess the spine, hips, sacroiliac joints and nerves. More than one source of pain is possible.
An X-ray may identify the anatomy. MRI or CT is considered when it would answer a specific question; everyone does not need both. In selected cases, an image-guided local anaesthetic injection can help test whether the additional articulation contributes to the familiar pain. The response supports clinical reasoning but is not an infallible test.
05What can help
Treatment usually starts with an individual plan for activity, exercise or physiotherapy and, when appropriate, pain medication chosen with a clinician. A finding without symptoms does not require treatment simply because it appears on an X-ray.
If pain persists, a specialist may discuss a targeted injection. Surgery is considered for selected patients after the suspected pain source and alternatives have been carefully assessed; it is not an automatic consequence of this finding.
If you also have inflammatory arthritis, keep following the agreed treatment plan. Do not stop or change a biologic solely because a transitional vertebra was found.
06Prepare for your visit
- Point to the usual pain and describe what makes it better or worse.
- Bring previous images and reports, including the dates.
- Ask: “What supports this being my pain source, and what other causes should we consider?”
- Agree on a practical goal and when to reassess the response.
When to seek urgent help
Seek urgent assessment for new loss of bladder or bowel control, inability to pass urine, numbness around the groin or saddle area, or new or rapidly worsening leg weakness. Fever with significant back pain, or severe pain after injury, also needs prompt assessment.
07Video transcript
01 · The question
PatientMy arthritis is in remission. So why does my back still hurt?
DoctorGood question. Two real patients will help us answer it. And the likely answer has a name: Bertolotti syndrome.
02 · Two women
DoctorMeet two women. One is 41 and African American. The other is 39, of European descent. Both have spondyloarthritis, an inflammatory arthritis of the spine.
PatientAnd both are being treated?
DoctorYes. Both take a biologic medicine, and in both the arthritis is in complete remission. And all doctors confirm it.
PatientBut they still have pain.
DoctorThey do. Low in the back, stronger on one side, and changing with position.
03 · What a false joint is
PatientSo where does that pain come from?
DoctorLook at the place where the spine meets the pelvis. The lowest vertebra of the spine has a small bony wing on each side. Usually these wings are short, and they touch nothing.
PatientAnd in these women?
DoctorIn some people, one wing is wide and long from birth. It reaches down to the sacrum, the bone at the base of the spine. The two bones meet at a spot where no joint was meant to be. Doctors call this a false joint.
PatientCan a false joint hurt?
DoctorIt can. Over the years it can wear, and it can hurt. That pain has a name: Bertolotti syndrome.
04 · The first patient on the X-ray
PatientCan you actually see it on an X-ray?
DoctorYes. This is the first patient, seen from the front. Her spine is in the middle, and her pelvis is on both sides. Now look at her left side. The shape outlined in blue is the wing of her lowest vertebra.
PatientIt looks wide.
DoctorIt is wide, and it comes all the way down to the sacrum. The circle marks the false joint.
05 · The second patient on the X-ray
PatientAnd the second patient?
DoctorHere she is, seen from the front again. The same wide wing, again on the left side. The blue line runs along the gap between the wing and the sacrum. That is her false joint.
PatientThe bone next to it looks whiter.
DoctorIt has become denser, which is a sign of wear.
06 · Remission on the X-ray
PatientAnd the arthritis itself? Where would that show?
DoctorIn a different place: the joints between the sacrum and the pelvis, circled here in gold. These are two X-rays of the second patient, taken less than a year apart.
PatientThey look the same to me.
DoctorExactly. The marks of her arthritis are the same on both. Nothing new has appeared. That is what remission looks like on an X-ray.
PatientAnd the false joint?
DoctorThe false joint, in blue, has not changed either. It is simply how her spine is built.
07 · Two reasons for back pain
PatientSo there are two kinds of back pain?
DoctorYes, two different reasons. Arthritis pain comes from inflammation. It is usually worst in the morning and after rest, and it eases with movement. A biologic medicine treats it.
PatientAnd the pain of a false joint?
DoctorThat pain is mechanical. It depends on position and on load, and it is often felt on one side.
PatientCan the biologic help with it?
DoctorNo. A biologic cannot change it, because the medicine treats inflammation, not the shape of a bone.
08 · What it means for you
PatientWhat does all this mean for me?
DoctorIf your arthritis is in remission and your back still hurts, it does not have to mean that the arthritis is back, or that your medicine has failed. In both of these women, the most likely cause is the same: the false joint.
PatientWhat should I do?
DoctorTell your rheumatologist exactly how your back hurts: where, on which side, and in which positions. A false joint is treated in its own way, and your doctor can tell you what is right for you.
08Sources & further reading
- Konin GP, Walz DM. Lumbosacral transitional vertebrae: classification, imaging findings, and clinical relevance. AJNR. 2010. Full text.
- Clinical assessment and management of Bertolotti Syndrome: a review of the literature. 2021. PubMed.
- Ramiro S, et al. ASAS–EULAR recommendations for the management of axial spondyloarthritis: 2022 update. Ann Rheum Dis. 2023. PubMed.
Patient interactive modules
Module 1 is an open demo. Modules 2–5 are free after registration; no paid subscription is required. · EN / RU / ES / PL
01 / 05 · High Stakes Carousel
Open demo
One Back, Two Reasons
Your arthritis is quiet, your back is not. Seven rounds on how both can be true at once — and what to do about it.
7 rounds · about 7 minutes
Open module →02 / 05 · High Stakes Carousel
Free after registration
What the Picture Leaves Out
A wing, a gap and a dashed oval: seven rounds on what an X-ray shows — and where its story stops.
7 rounds · about 7 minutes
Open module →03 / 05 · High Stakes Carousel
Free after registration
Where Exactly Does It Hurt?
Questions, hands, pictures and, now and then, a test injection: seven rounds on how the source of pain is tracked down.
7 rounds · about 7 minutes
Open module →04 / 05 · High Stakes Carousel
Free after registration
Step by Step, No Autopilot
From “leave it alone” to “let us talk about an injection”: seven rounds on what can help — and on what does not follow automatically.
7 rounds · about 7 minutes
Open module →05 / 05 · High Stakes Carousel
Free after registration
Packed for the Visit
What to bring, what to say, what to ask — and the few signs that do not wait for an appointment. Seven rounds before you go.
7 rounds · about 7 minutes
Open module →