RheumaView · Olga Goodman, MD
Bertolotti syndrome: anatomy, pain attribution and coexisting SpA
A concise clinical overview of transitional anatomy, pain attribution, vertebral numbering and management. The linked case page contains the teaching film, original radiographs and complete transcripts.
On this page
01Clinical essentials
- LSTV is an anatomical finding; Bertolotti syndrome requires a clinically supported association with pain. Do not equate the two.
- Localise the pain generator. The pseudoarticulation, adjacent disc, contralateral facet, sacroiliac joint or a compressed nerve may contribute.
- Confirmed remission and persistent pain can coexist. Consider an additional mechanical pain source while maintaining the established assessment of inflammatory disease.
- Confirm vertebral numbering before intervention. Communicate the counting method and reconcile imaging with the procedural target.
02Anatomy and clinical attribution
The supplied frontal study demonstrates an enlarged left transverse process forming an accessory articulation with the sacral region, with adjacent sclerosis and remodeling. The blue annotation identifies this anatomical relationship. It does not establish which structure generates pain. The image label deliberately says “lowest lumbar-type segment”: a cropped junctional radiograph cannot reliably establish vertebral numbering.
The accompanying overview and lateral view provide context. Sacroiliac joints, the segment above the transition, facets, discs and possible neural compression require separate assessment. Degenerative change and inflammatory disease can coexist; sclerosis alone is not specific for inflammatory sacroiliitis.
03Diagnosis and vertebral numbering
Start with the pain map, positional and loading features, neurologic examination, hip assessment and sacroiliac examination. Asymmetry or mechanical provocation may support a hypothesis but is not diagnostic. Review prior studies and their dates rather than attributing every symptom to the most conspicuous imaging finding. Consider other causes of low back pain, including discogenic or facet pain, radiculopathy, hip disease, fracture and active inflammatory disease when clinically indicated.
Radiographs often identify an LSTV. CT defines osseous morphology when the detail will affect management; MRI helps evaluate discs, nerves and suspected inflammatory changes. Avoid obtaining every modality routinely. When accurate enumeration matters, use appropriate whole-spine counting/localisers and reconcile rib-bearing segments, prior reports and procedural images. Describe any residual numbering uncertainty explicitly.
The Castellvi system describes morphology, not symptom causation or an automatic treatment choice. For this selected image set, left pseudoarticulation is the key teaching observation; a definitive numerical level and complete bilateral subtype are not assigned from the single annotated view.
Separate the structural description from the symptom hypothesis in the report. Specify side, the presence of a joint-like cleft or bony fusion, adjacent degeneration and any suspected neural compromise. A sacroiliac-region pain complaint does not identify the sacroiliac joint as its source; examination findings and image abnormalities need clinical concordance. Neither the absence of classic inflammatory pain features nor positional aggravation alone settles the differential.
Before an injection or operation, the radiologist and proceduralist should agree on the same numbered target using the available imaging. Transitional anatomy can shift usual assumptions about levels. Avoid silently translating a report that says “L5 versus S1” into a definite level in the procedural plan. Confirm rather than infer.
Castellvi classification: a compact reference
| Castellvi type | Morphology |
|---|---|
| I | Enlarged transverse process (classically at least 19 mm craniocaudally). |
| II | Incomplete transition with a diarthrodial pseudoarticulation. |
| III | Complete osseous fusion. |
| IV | Type II on one side and type III on the other. |
04Management: match the step to the question
For an incidental, asymptomatic LSTV, explain the finding without creating a treatment indication. For persistent pain, agree on functional goals and begin an individualised conservative programme: activity adaptation, graded exercise or physiotherapy, and analgesic options matched to comorbidities and risks. Avoid inferring that all loading is harmful or promising that exercise changes the underlying anatomy.
When the clinical pattern and imaging suggest the pseudoarticulation, an image-guided local anaesthetic injection, sometimes combined with corticosteroid, may provide diagnostic information and temporary relief. Record the target, familiar pain before and after, relevant provocative activities, timing and duration of response. Placebo effects, spread of injectate, multiple pain sources and variable follow-up limit causal interpretation; a positive response does not guarantee durable surgical benefit.
Persistent disabling symptoms despite appropriate conservative care may justify a multidisciplinary spine or pain referral. Radiofrequency procedures, resection and fusion have been described in selected patients. Selection should consider the suspected generator, adjacent degeneration, instability, neural involvement and patient priorities. Evidence is largely observational and heterogeneous; there is no single procedure justified by the Castellvi label alone.
A small retrospective surgical comparison reported greater long-term improvement after fusion than resection in its selected groups. This cannot establish that fusion is superior for every patient. A more recent retrospective injection cohort also found that immediate improvement was more common than sustained improvement at follow-up. These findings support realistic expectations and careful selection, not a universal sequence of procedures.
Agree on what a useful response would look like before starting treatment. Pain severity matters, but so do walking, sitting, sleep, work and return to valued activities. Record a baseline, reassess at a planned interval and distinguish short-lived relief from sustained functional improvement. A poor response should prompt reconsideration of the target and contributing conditions rather than automatic escalation to another procedure.
For a patient already receiving treatment for inflammatory arthritis, coordinate the mechanical pain plan with the treating rheumatologist. The presence of a second pain mechanism does not invalidate the original inflammatory diagnosis. Conversely, a developmental finding should not become a reason to stop looking when new symptoms or examination findings suggest another problem.
New bladder or bowel dysfunction, saddle sensory loss or progressive motor weakness requires urgent assessment. Fever with significant spinal pain, major trauma or other concerning clinical features calls for an appropriate urgent differential, not routine attribution to an LSTV.
05Confirmed remission and a second pain mechanism
The supplied films describe two women with HLA-B27-positive spondyloarthritis treated with secukinumab and residual asymmetric, positional low back pain. In these cases, remission was confirmed through the full clinical assessment and supporting investigations. The teaching question is why pain can persist despite confirmed remission.
The transitional anatomy provides a plausible additional mechanical contributor. Coexisting inflammatory disease and a developmental accessory articulation should be assessed as separate clinical problems. Prior MRI and radiographic findings are interpreted in their time context; structural findings may remain visible after inflammatory activity has been controlled.
For readers applying this example to a different patient, establish disease activity from the clinical picture, examination and appropriate investigations rather than inferring it from pain intensity or a single image. In the cases presented, the supplied materials do not include a diagnostic block response or a longitudinal response to targeted treatment establishing the pseudoarticulation as the dominant pain generator. The clinical hypothesis remains distinct from proof of a particular pain source.
Practical endpoint: name the anatomical finding, document the level-counting method, state the proposed pain mechanism and its uncertainty, and make the next diagnostic or therapeutic step answer a specific clinical question. Do not change SpA therapy solely because a transitional vertebra is identified.
06References and related reading
- Konin GP, Walz DM. Lumbosacral transitional vertebrae: classification, imaging findings, and clinical relevance. AJNR. 2010. Full text.
- Clinical assessment and management of Bertolotti Syndrome: a review of the literature. 2021. PubMed.
- Mikula AL, et al. Operative Treatment of Bertolotti Syndrome: Resection Versus Fusion. World Neurosurg. 2022. PubMed. Small retrospective comparison; treatment selection limits generalisation.
- Retrospective review of outcomes in patients with Bertolotti syndrome who underwent fluoroscopically-guided pseudojoint injections. 2025. Full text. Observational outcomes with incomplete follow-up.
- Ramiro S, et al. ASAS–EULAR recommendations for the management of axial spondyloarthritis: 2022 update. Ann Rheum Dis. 2023. PubMed.
Professional interactive modules
Free · Open to everyone · No registration required · EN / RU / ES / PL
The Wager
A Finding Is Not a Verdict
Questions on a transitional vertebra: what the film shows, what it cannot show, and what the numbers from the operating room and the injection suite really say.
8 questions from a pool of 12
Play →High Stakes Carousel
Two Sources on One Film
Seven rounds on a film that carries two stories at once — an inflammatory one and a mechanical one — and on keeping them apart from the report to the procedure request.
7 rounds · about 6 minutes
Play →Case Stakes
In remission — and it still hurts
Bertolotti syndrome. Decide where the remaining pain most likely comes from — and what must not be done about it.
4 hands · about 8 minutes
Play →