“My Grandma Has Arthritis.” What Family History Really Tells a Rheumatologist
An ordinary answer, and a family tree in which Grandma may not be the most medically interesting relative.
“Does anyone in your family have arthritis?”
“Yes, Doctor. My grandma has arthritis.”
I have a reply I use often enough that it probably deserves its own office stationery: “If you have a grandma, chances are you have a grandma with arthritis.”
It is a gentle joke, not a dismissal, and Grandma’s pain is entirely real. The trouble lies with the word. “Arthritis” is an enormous suitcase whose handle came off long ago. Inside you might find the ordinary osteoarthritis of older age, rheumatoid arthritis or gout, or a completely different condition that has been called “arthritis” ever since a cousin first mentioned it at Thanksgiving.
So my next question is always the same: “Which arthritis?” Two more stand right behind it. When did the trouble start, and who else in the family has a story worth hearing?

Congratulations. Your grandma has joints.
Osteoarthritis is the most common form of arthritis, and it becomes more common with every decade of life. So, in many families, does the conviction that young people do everything wrong, though only the first of these falls within my specialty. Knees that have carried someone through eighty years of stairs and grandchildren usually show some osteoarthritis, which is why a grandmother with sore knees at 84 tells me surprisingly little about your own risk of an inflammatory rheumatic disease.
Family osteoarthritis is not meaningless, though. When it starts unusually early, or turns up in the same joints across several relatives, it can carry real information; the knobby finger joints that some families seem to hand down along with the good china are a familiar example. Osteoarthritis: The Essentials explains what this condition is and what it is not.
Which arthritis, exactly?
“Arthritis” is a description that desperately needs a first name. Compare three things patients often tell me:
- “My grandmother was told she had knee osteoarthritis at 84.”
- “My mother’s hands swelled up at 34, and she was diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis.”
- “My brother has psoriasis, and I have had back pain since I was 24.”
The first statement is common and, taken alone, says relatively little. The second describes a specific inflammatory diagnosis, made early, in a first-degree relative (a parent, sibling or child). Having a parent or sibling with rheumatoid arthritis raises a person’s own risk roughly two- to fourfold; the increase is real, yet most relatives of people with rheumatoid arthritis never develop it. The disease itself is explained in Rheumatoid Arthritis: Patient Essentials.
The third statement never mentions arthritis at all, and it may well be the most interesting of the three. Psoriasis in a close relative, together with back pain that began in your twenties, raises a question about the spondyloarthritis family, where skin, spine, gut and eyes turn out to be more closely related than most people would guess. See Spondyloarthritis: The Essentials and Psoriatic Arthritis: The Essentials.
None of these stories is useless; they simply answer different questions. What separates them is a confirmed diagnosis and the age at which trouble began, weighed against how closely the relative is related to you.

The relative who never had arthritis
Sometimes the most useful relative is the one who has never complained about a knee. Such relatives rarely write “arthritis” on a medical form, which is exactly why patients leave them out. If any of the following genuinely runs in your family, mention it:
- psoriasis, including the kind that hides in the scalp or shows up only in the nails;
- Crohn’s disease or ulcerative colitis;
- uveitis, an inflammation inside the eye, ideally confirmed by an eye specialist rather than by a well-meaning cousin;
- certain autoimmune conditions, such as Sjögren’s disease, autoimmune thyroid disease, type 1 diabetes, celiac disease or vitiligo;
- unexplained fevers that keep coming back, sometimes with attacks of abdominal or chest pain.
These clues do not carry equal weight, and together they make no do-it-yourself rheumatism checklist. Each one means something only alongside your own symptoms and examination; what it can do is change which questions are worth asking. If autoimmunity or recurrent fevers are part of your family story, Early Autoimmunity: The Essentials and Autoinflammatory Conditions: Patient Essentials are good next reads.
One more family detail belongs on the list, even though it lies outside rheumatology: aneurysms or tears of major arteries in relatives at a young age. Tell your doctors about it; it deserves attention of its own.
“She had something autoimmune.”
This is a frequent sequel to the grandma conversation. “She had something autoimmune.” A promising start. Unfortunately, “autoimmune” is not a surname; it covers a large family of conditions whose members are often barely on speaking terms.
Many families keep medical history the way they keep recipes: by word of mouth, with the ingredients changing a little at every retelling. Nobody expects you to interrogate relatives over dinner or obtain a medical chart from 1978. Approximate memories still help. Try to recall roughly when the illness began and whether joints were actually swollen. Did a specialist treat it for years? Did the diagnosis come from a physician, or from family folklore?
“I don’t know the exact diagnosis, but my sister was treated for inflammatory arthritis in her twenties” is worth more than an invented certainty. It also helps to say which relative you mean. A parent or sibling is a far closer biological relative than a distant cousin, and a relative by marriage, however memorable their medical stories, does not belong in your inherited family history.
What to ask before your appointment
If family history may matter for your visit, try to find out five things:
- Who was affected, and how are they related to you?
- What was actually diagnosed? If nobody knows, what symptoms did they have?
- At what age did the problem begin?
- Were there important problems outside the joints, such as skin, eye, bowel or kidney trouble, unexplained fevers or unusual blood-vessel problems?
- Does anyone know the name of the condition, the specialist who treated it or an important treatment the relative received?
If the answer is “nobody knows,” say exactly that; an honest blank helps your doctor far more than a beautifully decorated guess.
A family tree is not a crystal ball
Family history shifts the odds without handing you a diagnosis. A relative with a rheumatic disease does not mean you will develop one, and a spotless family tree offers no immunity either; plenty of people are the first in their family to receive a particular diagnosis.
Nor is a family story a reason to start testing everyone at the reunion. Tests are chosen to answer a question about a person’s own symptoms. A positive ANA, for example, turns up in roughly one in seven Americans, most of whom are perfectly healthy.
You do not need to arrive with a family tree printed on architectural paper. A few accurate details and an honest account of your own symptoms will do, and deciding which connections matter is your clinician’s job.
So yes, tell me about Grandma’s arthritis. The family story that changes the diagnosis, however, may belong to a relative who has never once complained about a joint.
Educational information, not an individual diagnosis. This article does not recommend testing anyone solely because a relative has a particular condition.
Further reading: Frisell et al., Nat Rev Rheumatol (2016), familial risk of rheumatoid arthritis; Rudwaleit et al., Ann Rheum Dis (2009), ASAS classification criteria for axial spondyloarthritis; Satoh et al., Arthritis Rheum (2012), ANA prevalence in the United States.
The extended edition, “The Family Tree Has More Branches Than You Think,” is free after creating an account or signing in.
Read the six extended family stories · Free after registration